Where to Buy Local, Organic Eggs, Cheese, & Meats in Indianapolis

Eat local. Heal local. Live electric.If you're looking to stock your kitchen with clean, farm-fresh, and humanely raised food in Indianapolis, this guide is for you.

From grass-fed beef to raw milk cheese, pasture-raised eggs, and artisan sausages, our city has an amazing selection of local farms and butchers committed to sustainable agriculture and holistic health.

Below is your go-to list of Indy’s top farms and butchers — all with a commitment to integrity, quality, and nourishment.

🌾 Section 1:

Local Organic Farms & Farm Stores Near Indianapolis

🐄 1. Tyner Pond Farm – Pasture-Raised Everything

📍 Greenfield, IN (delivers to Indy)🔗 tynerpondfarm.com

What they offer:

• Grass-fed beef, pasture-raised pork & chicken

• A2/A2 raw milk cheese

• Free-range eggs

• Free delivery to Indy

Why we love it:Regeneratively raised animals, no antibiotics, no hormones, no BS. A top-tier source for clean proteins and dairy. Local delivery makes it super accessible.

🌱 2. Traders Point Creamery – Farm Fresh Dairy

📍 Zionsville, IN🔗 traderspointcreamery.com

What they offer:

• Organic, 100% grass-fed milk, cheese, and yogurt

• Butter, pasture-raised meats & eggs

• On-site creamery, café, and store

Why we love it:A beautiful property, incredible farm-to-table brunch, and some of the cleanest dairy in Indiana.

🥚 3. Little By Little Farm

📍 Brownsburg, IN🔗 littlebylittlefarm.com

What they offer:

• Organic, pasture-raised eggs

• Seasonal produce

• Home delivery via Market Wagon

Why we love it:Family-owned with a big heart. Weekly egg deliveries and veggie boxes bring simplicity and soul to your kitchen.

🧄 4. Mud Creek Farm

📍 9375 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN🔗 mudcreek.farm

What they offer:

• Farm-fresh eggs

• Seasonal vegetables

• Honor-system farm stand

Why we love it:Located in the Geist area, Mud Creek is a hidden gem for East Indy residents who want ultra-fresh produce and eggs.

🐖 5. Hoosier Heritage Farm

📍 Martinsville, IN (serves Indy)🔗 hoosierheritagefarm.com

What they offer:

• Grass-fed beef, pasture-raised pork & chicken

• Free-range eggs

• Farm store, local pickup & delivery

Why we love it:Ethical, local, small-batch farming with bulk and subscription options for families who want real food year-round.

🧺 6. Market Wagon – Virtual Farmer’s Market

📍 Online platform serving Indianapolis🔗 marketwagon.com

What they offer:

• Access to dozens of Indiana farms

• Pastured meats, raw milk, cheeses, eggs, & produce

• Weekly delivery to your doorstep

Why we love it:You can support multiple small farms in one order—convenient and community-focused.

🔪 Section 2: Sustainable Butchers & Meat Markets in Indianapolis

🥩 1. Goose the Market

📍 2503 N Delaware St, Indianapolis🔗 goosethemarket.com

Specialties:

• Cut-to-order beef, pork, poultry & game

• Pasture-raised, hormone-free meats

• House-made sausages, charcuterie, & gourmet groceries

Why we love it:Top-notch quality and customer service. Their focus on local sourcing and transparency is next level.

🍖 2. Smoking Goose Meatery

📍 411 Dorman St, Indianapolis🔗 smokinggoose.com

Specialties:

• Cured meats, salumi, smoked sausages

• Made in-house with local farm partners

• No preservatives, no artificial nitrates

Why we love it:Their meats are award-winning and thoughtfully made. Great for charcuterie boards and gift boxes, too.

🧂 3. Old Major Market

📍 4011 N Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis🔗 oldmajormarket.com

Specialties:

• Pastured pork, heritage bacon, sausages

• Small-batch smoked meats

• Local and regional farm partners

Why we love it:Perfect for bacon lovers and grillmasters who care where their food comes from.

🐂 4. Tyner Pond Farm Butcher Shop (Also in Farm Section Above)

📍 Greenfield, IN – with online store & delivery🔗 tynerpondfarm.com

Why we’re repeating it:It’s both a farm and a butcher, offering direct-to-consumer cuts without the middleman.

🌍 Bonus Mentions: Ask About Sourcing

Name	Location	Notes
Kincaid’s Meat Market	Indianapolis	Family-owned since 1921. Classic cuts, ask about sourcing. kincaidsmeatmarket.com
Moody’s Butcher Shop	Nora, Avon, Zionsville	Often partners with Indiana farms. moodysbutchershop.com
The Meat Shop of Indy	West Side	Claims no preservatives, no hormones. the-meat-shop.com
Don’s Butcher Shop	South Side	Old-school butcher; good selection. donsbutchershop.com
Claus’ German Sausage & Meats	Bates-Hendricks	Handcrafted deli meats, sausages. clausgermansausageandmeats.com

💡 Final Thoughts: Eat Better, Live Electric

Eating well doesn’t have to be complicated. By choosing local, organic, and pasture-raised foods, you’re not only fueling your body—you’re supporting a system of healing that ripples through your home, your neighborhood, and your city.

Let’s heal Indy, one meal at a time.